Publication date
1941
Booklets
Jehovah's Servants Defended
Publication page
15
../literature/booklets/1941-jsd/17/1941-jsd-17.html
JEHOVAH 
'S 
SERVANTS 
DEFENDED 
15 
-this 
bela, 
ill 
..eo"""'. 
with 
lbe 
decdaratlont 
of 
the 
W.t.eb 
TO'Wel' 
pliblier.tiClona." 
See 
,180 
DI'tIfI"" 
Ill. 
II. 
Oilll 
of 
.eu" 
.. 
j" 
(d, 
(At.y 
1941 
), 
F. 
Supp. 
by 
the 
United 
State. 
iatriet 
Court 
for 
the 
Western 
Diltriet 
of 
PennsylvUlia, 
declaring 
peddling 
and 
hawkers' 
or­ 
dinance 
invalid 
appUed 
to 
Jehovo.h'. 
'fI'\tn.e.. 
The 
ad 
that 
lIterarure 
III 
cl 
im 
ed 
to 
be 
old 
mlltte 
rs 
ot. 
In 
OommonWl"Uh 
(B 
orough 
of 
Clcarile 
ld 
v. 
eid 
et 
1ll:. 
June 
SO, 
19U), 
A. 
2d 
--. 
th 
PenD 
I)'!­ 
vania 
SUpe 
ri 
or 
Court 
eet 
uide 
conv 
etio 
ot 
two 
of 
Jehovah'. 
witnesses 
who 
were 
eonvieted 
01 
alleg&d 
se 
lliuglnd 
olleri 
), 
for 
sa1e 
literalure 
upon 
thenreell 
in 
violation 
of 
the 
borol§h 
ordinance. 
Th, 
ordinanee 
Will 
held 
In.-lid 
II 
applIed, 
.nd 
the 
court 
Aid: 
"'l", 
hiatoriea.l 
m~ 
t.) 
'P'J!Ipblew. 
ill 
that 
{lAwU 
,. 
Oilll 
01 
GriJJ_ 
aapn.] 
opmlOG 
ud 
In 
oI.htr 
opiD,­ 
of 
tbt 
court 
(Sehoeider 
.,. 
State 
.• 
Tbornhill 
". 
AJab.ma. 
310 
U.8. 
S8, 
1t7; 
••• 
elG.) 
Is 
not 
limitecl 
to 
'pampb 
ellr' 
whid. 
u. 
diRribuWl 
without 
eoet. 
Evu, 
stud~t 
of 
Io? 
Imo 
.... 
that 
u.. 
'pam 
pbifb 
refel'ftd 
IG 
b.r 
Chief 
JIQ\.i,oa 
BugMt 
in 
hi. 
pia 
iOll, 
nil. 
by 
Mr. 
JlUhOll 
Sulbtrla.od 
ill 
tb 
Of(llljou 
cue, 
"re 
nol 
ttr 
th 
llloat 
p4rt 
cil"llulMcd 
,raly, 
bul 
"e 
... 
diatributed 
ta 
.u~ri~ 
... 
or 
.., 
01.. 
'fhl)' 
'''ere 
the 
immediate 
prtde_ 
10 
.... 
of 
1Ifftkly 
ne-.papl'llS. 
.•• 
Cador 
Q_ 
AlIni 
pam­ 
phlet. 
arrived 
al 
rua.a.rbble 
dqlft 
ol 
lIaporb.aoe. 
Nonr 
lido 
.... 
or 
tinoe 
baa 
th~ 
method 
o.f 
pu 
blication 
been 
11M 
by 
loeb 
mute.... 
of 
hought 
I.IId 
~. 
Political 
omtin&" 
of 
aDY 
of 
aaLboritl 
.. 
Illmoat 
Jl.lltirel, 
_aaea 
to 
pulpbTet-. 
If 
tbe 
Wb, 
.. 
...... 
h~ 
IG 
command 
be 
_"ion 
of 
Addisoa 
nd- 
Steele, 
U:a 
Tori. 
foarbl 
with 
the 
terribJ, 
pea. 
of 
S.ill. 
EU"1eio­ 
pedi. 
Britanniea, 
Vol. 
20, 
Pamphleta,. 
pp. 
Mf.e60. 
'TLe 
r, 
ampblet 
ia 
popular 
.. 
au 
iMtl"'llDleG 
of 
reli';o. 
or 
,Ilea"! 
eoob-o'l'en, 
iJI. 
timet 
of. 
stn&. 
It 
it 
.... 
!ativ", 
111- 
upellli 
.,. 
to 
the 
plU'ehuer, 
llId 
to 
th, 
author 
or 
tl:. 
pllblitber 
it 
OUI 
be 
1110.-. 
limely 
thM 
book 
boond 
ill 
e10tb 
or 
lutber, 
IILDd 
it 
live. 
agLbor 
and 
"aden 
It 
.. 
JEHOVAH'S SERVANTS DEFENDED 15 —this being in accordance with the declarations of the Watch Tower publications.” See also Douglas et al. y. City of Jeannette et al. (May 2, 1941), _. F. Supp. —., by the United — fama — for the h ages Rat of ennsylvan aring a peddling an wkers’ ordinance invalid as applied to Jehovah’s witnesses. The fact that literature is claimed to be sold matters not, In Commonwealth (Borough of Clearfield) v. Reid et ux, (June 30, 1941), ... A. 2d —_, the Pennsylvania Superior Court set aside a conviction of two of Jehovah’s witnesses who were convicted of alleged sclling and offering for sale literature upon the streets in violation of the borough ordinance. The ordinance was held invalid as applied, and the court said: “The historical reference to ‘pamphlets’ in that [Lovell ¥. City of Griffin, supra] opinion and in other opinions of that court (Schneider v. State... ; Thornhill v. Alabama, 310 U.S. 88, 97; . . . ete.) is not limited to ‘pamphlets’ which are distributed without cost. Every student of history knows that the ‘pamphlets’ referred to by Chief Justice Hu in his opinion, and by Mr. Justice Sutherland in Grosjean case, were not for the moat part circulated gratis, but were distributed to subscribers or sold. They ‘were the immediate predecessors of weekly newspapers, ... Under Queen Anne pamhlets arrived at a remarkable degree of importanes. ever before or since has this method of publication been used by such masters of thought and language. Political = of any d of authority was almost entirely con: to ganopiole If the Whigs were able to command the services of Addison Steele, the pedia Britannica, Vol. 20, Pamphlets, pp. 659-660. ‘The a is popular as an instrument of religious or poitical controversy in times of stress. It is relatively in nsive to the purchaser, and to the author or the publisher it can be more timely than a book bound in eloth or leather, and it gives author and readers the

This website uses cookies to improve the website and your experience. By continuing to browse this website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. If you require further information or do not wish to accept cookies when using this website, please visit our Privacy Policy    Terms of Use    .