Publication date
4/15/07
Volume
28
Number
8
The WatchTower
Views from the Watch Tower
../literature/watchtower/1907/8/1907-8-2.html
(1I6-1I7) 
ZION'S 
WATCH 
TOWER 
ALLEGHENY, 
PA. 
PRESBYTERIAN 
MINISTER'S 
POINTED 
CRITICISM 
OF 
IDS 
CUm> 
The 
Toronto 
Evening 
Telegram 
giYes 
the 
following 
as 
the 
language 
of 
Rev. 
Dr. 
Carter 
in 
regard 
to 
the 
Westminster 
Confession 
of 
Faith:---I 
"The 
Westminster 
Confession 
in 
faet 
says 
that 
God 
is 
monster; 
modern 
theology 
says 
that 
he 
is 
not. 
Tamerlane 
built 
pyramid 
of 
two 
thousand 
men 
of 
the 
garrison 
of 
Herat, 
laid 
in 
brick 
and 
mortar, 
and 
history 
calls 
him 
monster 
for 
doing 
it. 
Lord 
Jeffreys 
presided 
over 
the 
'bloody 
circuit,' 
in 
which 
he 
condemned 
700 
to 
execution, 
and 
he 
stands 
scorned 
and 
by 
himself 
on 
the 
scroll 
of 
England's 
Chancellors. 
But 
Tamerlane 
and 
Jeffreys 
were 
sweet 
souls 
compared 
with 
God 
who 
could 
condemn 
whole 
race 
to 
endless 
torment 
for 
single 
sin. 
tlReaders 
of 
'Lorna 
Doone' 
will 
remember 
how 
the 
robber 
Doones 
of 
Bagworthy 
looted 
farmer's 
cottage 
and 
found 
little 
babe 
in 
its 
cradle. 
One 
of 
them 
called 
to 
his 
com­ 
rade 
to 
have 
game 
with 
him. 
He 
tossed 
the 
infant 
to 
the 
other, 
who 
caught 
it 
upon 
the 
point 
of 
his 
pike. 
We 
call 
these 
men 
fiends. 
but 
they 
were 
bright 
angels 
and 
seraphs 
com­ 
pared 
with 
God 
who 
could 
send 
millions 
of 
infants 
to 
eternal 
torments. 
"The 
moral 
sense 
of 
the 
people 
is 
shocked 
by 
the 
shilly­ 
shallying 
of 
the 
Presbyterian 
Church 
as 
to 
the 
Confession. 
The 
present 
connection 
of 
the 
Presbyterian 
Church 
with 
the 
Confession, 
if 
it 
were 
not 
so 
serious, 
would 
be 
farce; 
being 
so 
serious. 
it 
is 
crime. 
sham 
theology 
is 
sure 
to 
make 
sham 
religion." 
GET 
THEM 
TO 
STUDY 
MILLENNIAL 
DAWN 
The 
Westminster 
Teacher 
publishes 
with 
implied 
approval 
the 
following 
item 
from 
the 
columns 
of 
The 
Baptist 
Teacher:- 
LAMENTABLE 
LACK 
tlNever 
were 
there 
so 
many 
Bibles 
in 
the 
world 
as 
there 
are 
today. 
And 
never 
was 
the 
Bible 
so 
much 
praised. 
Never 
were 
there 
so 
many 
Sunday 
schools 
as 
now, 
and 
the 
one 
great 
purpose 
of 
the 
Sunday 
school 
is 
the 
study 
of 
the 
Bible. 
Yet 
even 
among 
the 
teachers 
in 
our 
Sunday 
schools 
the 
ignorance 
of 
the 
Bible 
is 
nothing 
less 
than 
deplorable; 
the 
proportion 
of 
gray 
heads 
among 
them 
is 
comparatively 
very 
small. 
The 
great 
majority 
of 
them 
are 
but 
novices 
in 
the 
Christian 
life, 
and 
they 
have 
enlisted 
in 
this 
service 
not 
because 
of 
any 
special 
fitness 
for 
it, 
but 
because 
there 
was 
lack 
of 
teachers, 
and 
their 
youthful 
zeal 
prompted 
them 
to 
enter 
door 
that 
seemed 
to 
open 
up 
field 
of 
usefulness. 
But 
their 
zeal 
was 
not 
according 
to 
knowledge. 
They 
were 
utterly 
unfurnished 
for 
so 
responsible 
task. 
They 
have 
been 
doing 
the 
best 
they 
could-poor 
things! 
How 
few 
of 
our 
Sunday 
school 
teachers 
have 
any 
conception 
of 
Scripture 
truth 
in 
its 
entirety 
-in 
its 
glorious 
symmetry 
How 
few 
of 
our 
Bible 
school 
teachers 
have 
any 
definite 
knowledge 
of 
the 
way 
in 
which 
our 
Bible, 
as 
we 
have 
it, 
came 
into 
being-of 
the 
canon 
of 
Scrip­ 
ture, 
of 
the 
proofs 
of 
the 
authenticity 
of 
the 
Scriptures, 
of 
the 
meaning 
of 
the 
inspiration 
of 
the 
Scriptures, 
of 
the 
rela­ 
tion 
of 
the 
Old 
and 
New 
Testament 
Scriptures, 
and 
the 
mean­ 
ing 
of 
all 
this 
hullabaloo 
that 
has 
been 
lately 
raised 
about 
the 
'higher 
criticism.' 
When 
confronted 
with 
questions 
raised 
by 
modern 
skepticism 
they 
are 
dumb 
and 
ashamed 
because 
of 
their 
utter 
ignorance. 
And 
these 
questions 
are 
apt 
at 
any 
time 
to 
be 
raised 
in 
the 
very 
classes 
that 
they 
teach. 
They 
have 
never 
had 
the 
advantage 
of 
any 
theological 
training, 
and 
why 
should 
they 
be 
expected 
to 
answer 
them' 
tlNow 
something 
ought 
to 
be 
done 
to 
remedy, 
if 
possible, 
this 
lamentable 
lack, 
and 
that 
teachers 
themselves 
should 
first 
be 
taught, 
so 
that 
when 
they 
come 
to 
teach 
they 
should 
not 
'mutter 
and 
peep,' 
but 
speak 
with 
no 
uncertain 
sound, 
and 
not 
only 
know, 
but 
know 
that 
they 
know, 
and 
so 
be 
able 
to 
render 
to 
every 
man 
that 
asketh 
them 
reason 
for 
the 
hope 
that 
is 
in 
them." 
There 
is 
truth 
in 
the 
above 
clipping. 
We 
are 
not 
defend­ 
ing 
thefts 
great 
or 
small, 
but 
readily 
agree 
that 
public 
in­ 
dignation 
is 
apt 
to 
be 
unjust-not 
only 
in 
including 
the 
bet­ 
ter 
with 
the 
worse, 
but 
also 
in 
showing 
no 
mercy 
on 
the 
err­ 
ing, 
even 
though 
it 
would 
be 
conceded 
that 
the 
majority 
would 
have 
done 
the 
same 
if 
they 
had 
possessed 
the 
opportunity. 
We 
cannot 
suppose 
that 
the 
rich 
of 
other 
lands 
are 
superior 
in 
morals 
either. 
Thpy 
may 
have 
seen 
less 
opportunity. 
or 
have 
not 
been 
exposed 
to 
such 
searching 
public 
examination. 
However, 
all 
this 
is 
exactly 
what 
the 
Bible 
led 
us 
to 
ex­ 
pect. 
revealing 
from 
the 
housetops 
and 
consequent 
break­ 
ing 
down 
of 
the 
respect 
of 
the 
masses 
for 
the 
upper 
classes, 
whose 
wealth 
is 
more 
and 
more 
coming 
to 
be 
recognized 
as 
GETTING 
READY 
FOR 
THE 
MILLENNIUM 
illegitimately 
secured. 
Thus 
is 
our 
present 
Lord 
guiding 
in 
Our 
amazement 
is 
excited 
by 
proposition 
to 
convert 
two- 
the 
affairs 
of 
earth 
toward 
the 
great 
climacteric 
of 
selfish 
and 
fifths 
of 
the 
area 
of 
the 
United 
States 
from 
arid 
lands 
into 
embittered 
anarchy-the 
predicted 
II 
time 
of 
trouble 
such 
as 
fertile 
farms. 
Yet 
this 
stupendous 
enterprise 
is 
seriously 
en­ 
was 
not 
since 
there 
was 
nation." 
tertained 
by 
the 
youngest 
division 
of 
our 
government. 
It 
We 
agree, 
then, 
that 
G. 
Le 
Bon 
is 
quite 
correct 
in 
his 
contemplates 
nothing 
less 
than 
the 
ultimate 
solving 
of 
the 
declaration 
that 
crowds 
and 
classes 
are 
often 
moved 
en 
masse 
50.000,000 
acres 
of 
waste 
comprising 
the 
great 
America"!l 
to 
do 
things 
that 
would 
not 
be 
considered 
by 
them 
as 
in- 
desert. 
The 
undertaking 
will 
involve 
the 
expenditure 
of 
$1,­ 
dividuals, 
and 
that 
the 
experiences 
of 
the 
French 
Revolution 
500,000, 
but 
it 
will 
create 
$2350,000,000 
worth 
of 
taxable 
will 
be 
duplicated 
throughout 
Christendom. 
Thank 
God 
that 
property, 
and 
will 
provide 
homes 
for 
3000,000 
of 
our 
future 
we 
can 
see 
silver 
lining 
to 
this 
cloud: 
that 
it 
will 
be 
fol- 
population. 
This 
is 
the 
prospective 
goal 
to 
which 
the 
bureau 
lowed 
speedily 
by 
the 
rise 
of 
the 
great 
Bun 
of 
Righteousness 
aspires, 
and 
its 
engineers 
declare 
that 
it 
is 
attainable 
within 
to 
heal 
and 
bless 
and 
enlighten 
II 
all 
the 
families 
of 
the 
earth." 
the 
present 
half-century.-Merchants' 
League 
Advocate. 
[3976J 
PSYCHOLOGICAL 
PHENOMENA 
"There 
are 
others 
beside 
economists 
who 
have 
turned 
to 
psychology 
in 
order 
to 
explain 
great 
movements, 
economic, 
socialistic 
or 
governmental. 
The 
master 
of 
them 
all 
is 
GUll­ 
tave 
Le 
Bon, 
author 
of 
the 
famous 
study 
on 
the' 
Psychology 
of 
Crowds.' 
In 
that 
work 
are 
the 
full 
explanations 
of 
such 
phenomena 
as 
this 
country 
is 
now 
witnessing 
in 
the 
ever­ 
increasing 
hostility 
to 
corporations, 
corporation 
managers, 
bankers, 
capitalists 
and 
men 
prominent 
in 
affairs. 
There 
is 
usually, 
unfortunately, 
basis 
for 
the 
fearful 
antipathy 
which 
is 
finally 
engendered 
among 
the 
'crowd' 
against 
the 
leaders. 
But 
this 
antipathy, 
small 
in 
the 
beginning 
is 
fostered 
and 
cultivated 
by 
pure 
reasoners 
and 
demagogues 
alike, 
until 
each 
offence, 
big 
or 
little, 
is 
magnified 
into 
some 
monstrous 
crime. 
Calm 
men 
are 
converted 
into 
ravening 
wolves, 
reasoning 
crea­ 
tures 
lose 
their 
sense 
of 
proportion, 
mere 
suspicion 
becomes 
confirmation 
of 
dreadful 
offences 
and 
men 
are 
condemned 
un­ 
heard 
and 
executed 
llnshriven. 
The 
French 
Revolution 
is 
case 
in 
point, 
psychological 
demonstration, 
and 
the 
spirit 
of 
one 
is 
developing 
now." 
moles 
and 
bats 
of 
godless, 
Christless 
scholarship 
that 
bur­ 
rows 
in 
the 
holy 
ground 
of 
Sinai 
and 
Calvary 
alike, 
finding 
there 
only 
cammon 
dirt. 
"Alas! 
It 
is 
only 
too 
true 
that 
the 
heavenly 
city 
which 
our 
Puritan 
fathers 
yearned 
for 
and 
sought 
with 
prayers 
anc] 
tears 
has 
become 
to 
many 
of 
their 
Christian 
descendants 
frigid 
city 
of 
ice 
palaces, 
built 
of 
pale 
negations, 
cold, 
cheerless, 
shining 
in 
pale 
winter 
sun 
with 
an 
evanescent 
glitter 
of 
doubtful 
and 
unsubstantial 
intellectual 
worth. 
"The 
full, 
rich, 
glorious 
Christ 
of 
Catholic 
Christianity 
has 
been 
dragged 
from 
his 
throne 
by 
these 
'advanced 
thinkers' 
-God 
save 
the 
mark!-and 
reduced 
to 
beggary. 
pale, 
bloodless, 
emaciated 
Syrian 
ghost, 
he 
still 
dimly 
haunts 
the 
icy 
corridors 
of 
this 
twentieth 
century 
Protestantism, 
from 
which 
the 
doom 
of 
his 
final 
exclusion 
has 
been 
already 
spoken. 
"Then 
in 
their 
boundless 
arrogance 
and 
self-assertion 
they 
turn 
upon 
those 
of 
us 
who 
still 
cry 
with 
Thomas 
before 
the 
Risen 
One, 
'my 
Lord 
and 
my 
God,' 
and 
tell 
us 
that 
there 
is 
no 
middle 
ground 
between 
their 
own 
vague 
and 
sterile 
ration­ 
alism 
and 
the 
Roman 
Catholic 
Church. 
If 
this 
be 
so, 
then 
for 
me 
most 
gratefully 
and 
lovingly 
turn 
to 
the 
Church 
of 
Rome 
as 
homeless, 
houseless 
wanderer 
to 
home 
in 
con­ 
tinuing 
city. 
We 
are 
hungry 
for 
God, 
yea, 
for 
the 
living 
God, 
and 
hence 
so 
restless 
and 
dissatisfied. 
The 
husk 
of 
life's 
fruit 
is 
growing 
thicker, 
and 
its 
meat 
thinner 
and 
dryer 
every 
day 
for 
the 
vast 
majority 
of 
our 
people. 
In 
many 
and 
important 
respects 
life 
was 
brighter 
in 
the 
so-called 
'Dark 
Ages' 
than 
it 
is 
today. 
The 
seamless 
robe 
of 
Christ 
is 
rent 
into 
hideous 
fragments 
and 
trampled 
in 
the 
dirt. 
"It 
is 
not 
all 
good 
that 
we 
have 
inherited 
from 
our 
Puri­ 
tan 
and 
Pilgrim 
sires. 
We 
have 
been 
talking 
about 
civil 
and 
religious 
liberty 
as 
if 
that 
were 
the 
only 
thing 
in 
the 
world. 
Noting 
the 
use 
the 
average 
man 
and 
woman 
makes 
of 
this 
boasted 
liberty 
today, 
one 
is 
inclined 
to 
think 
it 
would 
be 
far 
better 
for 
them 
if 
they 
had 
less 
liberty 
and 
more 
law.' 
,­ 
Boston 
American. 
(116-117) moles and bats of a godless, Christless scholarship that burrows in the holy ground of Sinai and Calvary alike, finding there only cammon dirt. ‘* Alas! It is only too true that the heavenly city which our Puritan fathers yearned for and sought with prayers and tears has become to many of their Christian descendants a frigid city of ice palaces, built of pale negations, cold, cheerless, shining in a pale winter sun with an evanescent glitter of a doubtful and unsubstantial intellectual worth. ‘The full, rich, glorious Christ of Catholic Christianity has been dragged from his throne by these ‘advanced thinkers’ ——God save the mark!—and reduced to beggary. A pale, bloodless, emaciated Syrian ghost, he still dimly haunts the icy corridors of this twentieth century Protestantism, from which the doom of his final exclusion has been already spoken. ‘‘Then in their boundless arrogance and self-assertion they turn upon those of us who still cry with Thomas before the Risen One, ‘my Lord and my God,’ and tell us that there is no middle ground between their own vague and sterile rationalism and the Roman Catholic Church. If this be so, then for me most gratefully and lovingly I turn to the Church of Rome as a homeless, houseless wanderer to a home in a continuing city. ‘¢We are hungry for God, yea, for the living God, and hence so restless and dissatisfied. The husk of life’s fruit is growing thicker, and its meat thinner and dryer every day for the vast majority of our people. In many and important respects life was brighter in the so-called ‘Dark Ages’ than it is today. The seamless robe of Christ is rent into hideous fragments and trampled in the dirt. “‘It is not all good that we have inherited from our Puritan and Pilgrim sires. We have been talking about civil and religious liberty as if that were the only thing in the world. Noting the use the average man and woman makes of this boasted liberty today, one is inclined to think it would be far better for them if they had less liberty and more law.’’— Boston American, PSYCHOLOGICAL PHENOMENA ‘‘There are others beside economists who have turned to psychology in order to explain great movements, economic, socialistic or governmental. The master of them all is Gustave Le Bon, author of the famous study on the ‘ Psychology of Crowds.’ In that work are the full explanations of such phenomena as this country is now witnessing in the everincreasing hostility to corporations, corporation managers, bankers, capitalists and men prominent in affairs. There is usually, unfortunately, a basis for the fearful antipathy which is finally engendered among the ‘crowd’ against the leaders. But this antipathy, small in the beginning is fostered and cultivated by pure reasoners and demagogues alike, until each offence, big or little, is magnified into some monstrous crime. Calm men are converted into ravening wolves, reasoning creatures lose their sense of proportion, mere suspicion becomes confirmation of dreadful offences and men are condemned unheard and excented unshriven. The French Revolution is a case in point, a psychological demonstration, and the spirit of one is developing now.’’ * * * There is truth in the above clipping. We are not defending thefts great or small, but readily agree that publie indignation is apt to be unjust—not only in including the better with the worse, but also in showing no mercy on the erring, even though it would be conceded that the majority would have done the same if they had possessed the opportunity. We cannot suppose that the rich of other lands are superior in morals either. They may have seen less opportunity. or have not been exposed to such a searching public examination. However, all this is exactly what the Bible led us to expect. A revealing from the housetops and a consequent breaking down of the respect of the masses for the upper classes, whose wealth is more and more coming to be recognized as illegitimately secured. Thus is our present Lord guiding in the affairs of earth toward the great climacteric of selfish and embittered anarchy—the predicted ‘‘time of trouble such as was not since there was a nation.’’ We agree, then, that G. Le Bon is quite correct in his declaration that crowds and classes are often moved en masse to do things that would not be considercd by them as individuals, and that the experienecs of the French Revolution will be duplicated throughout Christendom. Thank God that we can see a silver lining to this cloud: that it will be followed speedily by the rise of the great Sun of Righteousness to heal and bless and enlighten ‘‘all the families of the earth.’’ ZION’S WATCH TOWER ALLEGHENY, Pa. GET THEM TO STUDY MILLENNIAL DAWN The Westminster Teacher publishes with implied approval the following item from the columns of The Baptist Teacher :— A LAMENTABLE LACK ‘*Never were there so many Bibles in the world as there are today. And never was the Bible so much praised. Never were there so many Sunday schools as now, and the one great purpose of the Sunday school is the study of the Bible. Yet even among the teachers in our Sunday schools the ignorance of the Bible is nothing less than deplorable; the proportion of gray heads among them is comparatively very small. The great majority of them are but novices in the Christian life, and they have enlisted in this service not because of any special fitness for it, but because there was a lack of teachers, and their youthful zeal prompted them to enter a door that seemed to open up a field of usefulness, But their zeal was not according to knowledge. They were utterly unfurnished for so responsible a task. They have been doing the best they could—poor things! . . . How few of our Sunday school teachers have any conception of Scripture truth in its entirety —in its glorious symmetry! How few of our Bible school teachers have any definite knowledge of the way in which our Bible, as we have it, came into being—of the canon of Scripture, of the proofs of the authenticity of the Scriptures, of the meaning of the inspiration of the Scriptures, of the relation of the Old and New Testament Scriptures, and the meaning of all this hullabaloo that has been lately raised about the ‘higher criticism.’ When confronted with questions raised by modern skepticism they are dumb and ashamed because of their utter ignorance. And these questions are apt at any time to be raised in the very classes that they teach. They have never had the advantage of any theological training, and why should they be expected to answer them? ‘Now something ought to be done to remedy, if possible, this lamentable Jack, and that teachers themselves should first be taught, so that when they come to teach they should not ‘mutter and peep,’ but speak with no uncertain sound, and not only know, but know that they know, and so be able to render to every man that asketh them a reason for the hope that is in them.’’ A PRESBYTERIAN MINISTER’S POINTED CRITICISM OF HIS CREED The Toronto Evening Telegram gives the following as the language of Rev. Dr. Carter in regard to the Westminster Confession of Faith:— ‘‘The Westminster Confession in fact says that God is a monster; modern theology says that he is not. Tamerlane built a pyramid of two thousand men of the garrison of Herat, laid in brick and mortar, and history calls him a monster for doing it. Lord Jeffreys presided over the ‘bloody circuit,’ in which he condemned 700 to execution, and he stands scorned and by himself on the scroll of England’s Chancellors. But Tamerlane and Jeffreys were sweet souls compared with a God who could condemn a whole race to endless torment for a single sin. ‘Readers of ‘Lorna Doone’ will remember how the robber Doones of Bagworthy looted a farmer’s cottage and found a little babe in its cradle. One of them called to his comrade to have a game with him. He tossed the infant to the other, who caught it upon the point of his pike. We call these men fiends, but they were bright angels and seraphs compared with a God who could send millions of infants to eternal torments. ‘*The moral sense of the people is shocked by the shillyshallying of the Presbyterian Church as to the Confession. The present connection of the Presbyterian Church with the Confession, if it were not so serious, would be a farce; being so serious, it is a crime. A sham theology is sure to make a sham religion.’’ GETTING READY FOR THE MILLENNIUM Our amazement is excited by a proposition to convert twofifths of the area of the United States from arid lands into fertile farms. Yet this stupendous enterprise is seriously entertained by the youngest division of our government. It contemplates nothing less than the ultimate solving of the 50,000,000 acres of waste comprising the great American desert. The undertaking will involve the expenditure of $1,500,000, but it will create $2 350,000,000 worth of taxable property, and will provide homes for 3 000,000 of our future population. This is the prospective goal to which the bureau aspires, and its engineers declare that it is attainable within the present half-century.—Merchants’ League Advocate. [3976]

This website uses cookies to improve the website and your experience. By continuing to browse this website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. If you require further information or do not wish to accept cookies when using this website, please visit our Privacy Policy    Terms of Use    .