Publication date
8/15/08
Volume
29
Number
16
The WatchTower
Our Western Convention Tour
/../literature/watchtower/1908/16/1908-16-1.html
 
 
VOL. 
XXIX 
ALLEGHENY, 
PA., 
SEPTEMBER 
1,1908 
VIEWS 
FROM 
THE 
WATCH 
TOWER 
No. 
17 
DISCOURAGED 
PREACHERS 
Ministers 
are 
reported 
by 
one 
of 
their 
number 
to 
be 
in 
permanent 
condition 
of 
"Blue 
Monday." 
The 
editor 
of 
The 
Standard 
(Baptist, 
Chicago) 
informs 
us 
that 
he 
was 
told 
by 
friend 
not 
long 
ago 
that 
"nine-tenths 
of 
all 
the 
preachers 
in 
his 
circle 
of 
acquaintances 
are 
discouraged." 
This 
.same 
Jeremiah 
"asserted 
that 
the 
great 
majority 
of 
pastors 
are 
practically 
hopeless 
of 
accomplishing 
anJ'-thing 
worth 
while; 
that 
they 
are 
restless 
and 
discontented, 
and 
heartily 
wish 
that 
they 
had 
never 
entered 
the 
ministry." 
If 
he 
is 
right, 
the 
editor 
of 
The 
Standard 
observes, 
"we 
may 
add 
another 
to 
the 
tabulated 
reasons 
why 
young 
men 
do 
not 
enter 
the 
ministry." 
The 
editor 
thinks 
that 
the 
preacher, 
under 
stress 
of 
unusual 
discouragement 
himself, 
is 
mistaken, 
but 
the 
Rev. 
Dr. 
Aked, 
in 
recent 
sermon 
on 
the 
alleged 
decay 
of 
Christianity 
in 
New 
York, 
practically 
asserted 
the 
same 
facts 
as 
falling 
under 
his 
observation 
when 
he 
first 
visited 
America. 
As 
quoted 
by 
The 
Examiner 
(New 
York), 
his 
words 
are: 
"One 
of 
the 
things 
that 
impressed 
me 
most 
when 
came 
here 
for 
month 
in 
the 
autumn 
of 
1906, 
was 
the 
depression 
of 
so 
many 
preachers 
and 
recognized 
leaders 
in 
the 
churches 
of 
this 
city. 
met 
many 
representatives 
of 
the 
denominations, 
and 
their 
discouragement 
about 
Chris­ 
tian 
work 
in 
this 
city 
seemed 
very 
strange 
to 
me. 
'It 
was 
unlike 
anything 
had 
observed 
on 
previous 
vi.sits, 
reaching 
back 
about 
fifteen 
years. 
It 
seemed 
to 
me, 
also, 
so 
unlike 
yourselves. 
The 
American 
people 
are 
not 
easily 
discouraged. 
There 
is 
in 
you 
buoyancy 
of 
spirit, 
an 
irrepressible 
vitality, 
an 
intellectual 
and 
emo­ 
tional 
agility 
which 
smiles 
in 
the 
face 
of 
difficulty. 
"We 
English 
people 
have 
shown 
through 
many 
centuries 
the 
grim 
determination 
we 
possess, 
and 
our 
Yorkshire 
say­ 
ing, 
'It's 
dogged 
as 
does 
it,' 
represents 
national 
char­ 
acteristic. 
With 
you 
it 
is 
different. 
It 
is 
not 
'grimness' 
nor 
'doggedness' 
that 
find 
in 
you 
so 
much 
as 
joyous 
and 
.sunny 
disregard 
of 
difficulty, 
and 
the 
easy 
assurance 
of 
victory 
everywhere, 
which 
itself 
is 
more 
than 
half 
the 
battle, 
so 
that 
this 
attitude 
toward 
the 
problems 
of 
religious 
life 
struck 
me 
as 
significant. 
"I 
have 
heard 
much 
of 
that 
kind 
of 
talk 
since 
came 
here 
more 
than 
twelve 
months 
ago. 
First, 
one 
well-known 
preacher 
or 
worker 
and 
then 
another 
has 
shown 
that 
in 
his 
opinion 
Christianity 
is 
not 
holding 
its 
own 
in 
this 
city. 
And 
lately 
some 
remarkable 
utterances 
have 
reached 
the 
public 
ear." 
The 
editor 
of 
The 
Standard 
attempts 
to 
furnish 
healing 
balm 
to 
the 
cases 
that 
may 
come 
under 
the 
preacher's 
clas­ 
sification. 
We 
read: 
'To 
be 
sure, 
almost 
every 
man, 
in 
the 
ministry 
CIl' 
out, 
has 
his 
hours 
of 
depression. 
The 
minister 
who 
goes 
home 
from 
the 
Sunday 
evening 
service 
after 
speaking 
to 
hand­ 
ful 
of 
people, 
majority 
of 
whom 
are 
not 
members 
of 
his 
church, 
somewhat 
worn 
by 
the 
wark 
of 
the 
day, 
casting 
about 
in 
his 
mind 
for 
something 
upon 
which 
to 
preach 
on 
the 
following 
Sunuay, 
carrying 
in 
his 
heart 
the 
news, 
just 
mauc 
known 
to 
him, 
that 
one 
of 
his 
best 
families 
will 
.soon 
remove 
to 
distant 
State, 
will 
doubtless 
feel 
cast 
down. 
But 
even 
so, 
his 
cOlll'age 
is 
not 
utterly 
destroyed. 
After 
good 
night's 
rest 
and 
talk 
with 
his 
Master, 
he 
goes 
about 
the 
tasks 
of 
the 
new 
week 
with 
good 
measure 
of 
hope 
in 
his 
heart. 
The 
man 
who 
is 
permanently 
disheartened 
by 
one 
difficulty, 
or 
two 
or 
three 
or 
dozen, 
ought 
not 
to 
be 
in 
the 
ministry. 
In 
fact, 
it 
is 
difficult 
to 
think 
of 
place 
in 
this 
world 
where 
he 
ought 
to 
be, 
for 
there 
is 
not 
worthy 
activity 
of 
man 
that 
can 
be 
continuously 
prose­ 
cuted 
without 
meeting 
obstacles. 
The 
lawyer, 
the 
physician, 
the 
fal'l11er, 
the 
merchant-each 
has 
his 
peculiar 
trials. 
If 
he 
amounts 
to 
anything' 
among 
men 
he 
mu.st 
no 
his 
work 
in 
spite 
of 
discouragements. 
The 
minister 
is 
no 
exception 
to 
the 
general 
rule.' 
'-Lttc'taI'JJ 
Dtgest. 
TOLSTOI 
AND 
THE 
PEASANT 
Not 
long 
ago 
small 
party 
called 
on 
Tolstoi, 
of 
whom 
Ivanhoff 
was 
one. 
One 
of 
the 
visitars 
first 
conversed 
with 
the 
Count 
about 
political 
and 
social 
matters. 
Then 
Ivan­ 
hoff's 
turn 
came. 
He 
wa.s 
resolve.] 
to 
hear 
from 
Tolstoi's 
own 
lips 
his 
religious 
position. 
The 
following' 
canversation 
ensu~d. 
"Who 
are 
you'" 
aske.] 
Count 
Tolstoi. 
"I 
am 
only 
1'I 
peasant," 
answered 
Ivanhoff. 
"What 
have 
you 
got 
to 
5ay 
to 
me'" 
was 
the 
next 
question. 
'I 
wish 
to 
knaw 
your 
opinion 
about 
Jesus 
Chri.st, 
and 
about 
the 
Holy 
Scriptures 
1" 
"With 
regard 
to 
.Tesus 
Christ, 
there 
is 
noth­ 
ing 
to 
be 
said," 
answered 
the 
Count. 
"His 
Personality 
is 
not 
necessary 
to 
us, 
only 
his 
teaching." 
"That 
is 
very 
.strange," 
said 
Ivanhoff; 
"if 
found 
letter 
in 
the 
street, 
the 
contents 
of 
which 
interested 
me, 
would 
do 
all 
could 
to 
find 
out 
who 
had 
written 
it. 
For 
me, 
at 
any 
rate, 
the 
writer 
is 
of 
more 
consequence 
than 
the 
letter. 
The 
writer 
can 
write 
one 
hundred 
other 
letters 
equally 
good, 
as 
this 
first 
letter. 
He 
himself, 
therefore, 
is 
of 
more 
interest 
to 
me 
than 
the 
letter. 
If 
do 
not 
know 
him, 
can 
only 
have 
this 
one 
letter; 
but 
if 
am 
acquainted 
with 
him, 
may 
be 
able 
to 
receive 
hundred 
letters 
be­ 
sides.' 
"As 
you 
really 
want 
to 
know 
what 
think 
of 
Jesus, 
will 
tell 
you," 
said 
Tolstoi. 
"For 
me, 
Jesus 
Christ 
is 
good 
man, 
man 
such 
as 
all 
men 
ought 
to 
?e. 
You 
and.I 
ought 
to 
be 
just 
as 
he 
was. 
But 
to 
call 
hIm 
God, 
that 
IS 
blasphemy. 
As 
regards 
the 
Holy 
Scriptures, 
take 
this 
Bible 
in 
your 
hand. 
The 
Old 
Testament, 
don't 
read 
it; 
rather 
tear 
it 
out 
and 
throw 
it 
away. 
The 
Old 
Testament 
only 
causes 
as 
the 
Dukhabors 
rightly 
say, 
great 
deal 
of 
work 
and 
~ly 
leans 
to 
trouble. 
Then 
there 
remains 
the 
New 
Testament. 
Take 
the 
book 
of 
Acts 
and 
the 
Epistles, 
and 
then 
take 
Revelation; 
tear 
them 
out 
and 
throw 
them 
away. 
You 
have 
then 
only 
the 
four 
Gospels 
left. 
Take 
these 
Gospels 
read 
them 
through 
and 
think 
over 
them. 
There 
are 
wo;a.s 
there 
that 
Jesus 
said, 
and 
the 
Apostles 
have 
writ­ 
ten 
down' 
there 
are 
also 
words 
that 
the 
Apostles 
have 
writ­ 
ten 
of 
themselves. 
All 
that 
the 
Apostles 
have 
written, 
tear 
out 
and 
throwaway. 
Now 
you 
retain 
only 
the 
words 
that 
Jesus 
himself 
spoke. 
Of 
these, 
there 
are 
two 
classes. 
Some 
of 
the 
words 
are 
dim 
and 
mysterious, 
and 
hard 
to 
understand. 
Lay 
them 
aside. 
It 
is 
best 
for 
you 
not 
to 
read 
them. 
Then 
you 
have 
left 
only 
the 
clear 
words, 
especially 
the 
Sermon 
on 
the 
Mount. 
Read 
it, 
for 
it 
is 
the 
teaching 
of 
Jesus. 
In 
this 
way, 
you 
will 
become 
Christian." 
"Leo 
Nikolajewitsch," 
answered 
vanhoff, 
"I 
have 
un­ 
derstood 
what 
you 
have 
said. 
But 
you 
have 
not 
given 
me 
any 
right 
to 
do 
that 
which 
you 
have 
said. 
In 
one 
of 
the 
books 
you 
left 
me 
to 
retain 
is 
passage 
spoken 
by 
Jesus 
Christ 
that 
says: 
'0 
fools, 
and 
slow 
of 
heart 
to 
believe 
all 
th~t 
the 
prophets 
have 
spoken.' 
(Luke 
24:25.) 
You 
said 
to 
me, 
that 
should 
throwaway 
the 
Old 
Testament; 
but 
Christ 
himself-whom 
you 
call 
good 
man-has 
com­ 
manded 
me 
to 
believe 
it 
all, 
therefore 
also 
the 
prophets. 
hold 
that 
have 
no 
right 
to 
throwaway 
any 
book; 
yea, 
even 
more, 
that 
have 
no 
right 
to 
throwaway 
anyone 
word 
that 
he 
has 
commanded 
me 
to 
believe." 
Tolstoi 
was 
evidently 
very 
uncomfortable. 
He 
took 
the 
Bible 
from 
Ivanhoff's 
hand, 
threw 
it 
on 
the 
table, 
and 
be­ 
gan 
walking 
up 
and 
down 
the 
room 
in 
an 
annoyed 
mood. 
Suddenly 
he 
stopped 
in 
front 
of 
Ivanhoff, 
and 
looking 
him 
straight 
in 
the 
face 
said, 
"It 
would 
interest 
me 
to 
know 
what 
you 
think 
of 
me?" 
Ivanhoff's 
friend 
wanted 
to 
come 
to 
his 
help, 
but 
he 
held 
him 
back 
saying: 
"If 
the 
Count 
had 
asked 
you, 
you 
could 
answer, 
but 
now 
he 
has 
asked 
me, 
and 
want 
to 
an 
swer 
him 
myself." 
He 
turned 
to 
Tolstoi 
saying: 
'I 
will 
tell 
you. 
In 
one 
of 
the 
books 
that 
you 
told 
me 
to 
take 
out 
and 
throwaway, 
the 
Acts, 
is 
story 
about 
pious 
man, 
who 
gave 
many 
alms 
and 
always 
prayed 
to 
God. 
As 
you 
see, 
this 
man 
had 
the 
following 
virtues: 
He 
was 
God­ 
fearing, 
merciful, 
did 
many 
good 
deeds, 
and 
he 
prayed­ 
and 
yet, 
he 
was 
not 
Christian. 
But 
an 
angel 
appeared 
to 
him 
and 
commanded 
that 
he 
should 
send 
to 
Joppa 
and 
call 
Simon 
Peter, 
who 
would 
tell 
him 
what 
to 
do 
to 
be 
saved. 
And 
when 
Cornelius 
had 
fetched 
Peter 
and 
heard 
his 
words 
he 
became 
Christian. 
Corneliu.s 
had, 
as 
you 
see, 
the 
fol­ 
lowing 
excellent 
qUlllities: 
He 
was 
pious, 
God-fearing, 
be­ 
nevolent, 
and 
he 
prayed. 
In 
you, 
Leo 
Nikolajewitsch, 
there 
is 
not 
even 
all 
these, 
because 
you 
do 
not 
pray. 
And 
as 
you 
do 
not 
pray, 
cannot 
call 
you 
Christian." 
Tolstoi 
again 
began 
to 
walk 
to 
and 
fro 
in 
the 
room. 
At 
last 
he 
said: 
"When 
chicken 
has 
once 
come 
out 
O'f 
the 
shell, 
it 
cannot 
be 
put 
back." 
With 
this 
Russian 
proverb, 
the 
conversation 
ended. 
"I 
have 
since 
told 
this 
little 
incident- 
to 
several 
of 
Tol­ 
stoi's 
admirers," 
adds 
vanhoff. 
"They 
could 
hardly 
be­ 
lieve 
that 
had 
dared 
to 
speak 
out 
so 
freely, 
because 
Tolstoi 
is 
to 
many 
thousand.s 
of 
the 
younger 
Russians 
almost 
an 
idol. 
It 
is 
said." 
remarked 
Ivanhoff 
at 
the 
close, 
"that 
Tolstoi 
has 
now 
begun 
to 
pray. 
If 
this 
man 
becomes 
Christian, 
he 
would 
be 
Russia's 
Luther.' 
'-Quarterly 
Review. 
MRS. 
EDDY'S 
ABSURD 
IDEAS 
OF 
THE 
BIBLE 
Mrs. 
Eddy's 
exegetical 
theorie.s 
are 
dealt 
with 
in 
the 
final 
article 
on 
the 
history 
of 
Christian 
Science 
in 
the 
June 
McClure's. 
The 
writer, 
Georgine 
Milmine, 
makes 
copious 
[4230] 
Vou. XXIX ALLEGHENY, PA., SEPTEMBER 1, 1908 No. 17 VIEWS FROM THE WATCH TOWER DISCOURAGED PREACHERS Ministers are reported by one of their number to be in a permanent condition of ‘‘Blue Monday.’’ The editor of The Standard (Baptist, Chicago) informs us that he was told by a friend not long ago that ‘‘nine-tenths of all the preachers in his circle of acquaintances are discouraged.’’ This same Jeremiah ‘‘asserted that the great majority of pastors are practically hopeless of accomplishing anything worth while; that they are restless and discontented, and heartily wish that they had never entered the ministry.’’ If he is right, the editor of The Standard observes, ‘‘we may add another to the tabulated reasons why young men do not enter the ministry.’’ The editor thinks that the preacher, under stress of unusual discouragement himself, is mistaken, but the Rev. Dr. Aked, in a recent sermon on the alleged decay of Christianity in New York, practically asserted the same facts as falling under his observation when he first visited America. As quoted by The Hxaminer (New York), his words are: “One of the things that impressed me most when [ eame here for a month in the autumn of 1906, was the depression of so many preachers and recognized leaders in the churches of this city. I met many representatives of the denominations, and their discouragement about Christian work in this city seemed very strange to me. ‘It was unlike anything I had observed on previous visits, reaching back about fifteen years. It seemed to me, also, so unlike yourselves. The American people are not easily discouraged. There is in you a buoyancy of spirit, an irrepressible vitality, an intellectual and emotional agility which smiles in the face of difficulty. ‘We English people have shown through many centuries the grim determination we possess, and our Yorkshire saying, ‘It’s dogged as does it,’ represents a national characteristic. With you it is different. It is not ‘grimness’ nor ‘doggedness’ that I find in you so much as a joyous and sunny disregard of difficulty, and the easy assurance of victory everywhere, which itself is more than half the battle, so that this attitude toward the problems of religious life struck me as significant. ‘‘T have heard much of that kind of talk since I came here more than twelve months ago. First, one well-known preacher or worker and then another has shown that in his opinion Christianity is not holding its own in this city. And lately some remarkable utterances have reached the publie ear.’’ The editor of The Standard attempts to furnish healing balm to the cases that may come under the preacher’s classification. We read: “(To be sure, almost every man, in the ministry or out, has his hours of depression. The minister who goes home from the Sunday evening service after speaking to a handful of people, a majority of whom are not members of his church, somewhat worn by the work of the day, casting about in his mind for something upon which to preach on the following Sunday, carrying in his heart the news, just made known to him, that one of his best families will soon remove to a distant State, will doubtless feel cast down. But even so, his courage is not utterly destroyed. After a good night’s rest and a talk with his Master, he goes about the tasks of the new week with a good measure of hope in his heart. The man who is permanently disheartened by one difficulty, or two or three or a dozen, ought not to be in the ministry. In fact, it is difficult to think of a place in this world where he ought to be, for there is not a worthy activity of man that can be continuously proseeuted without meeting obstacles. The lawyer, the physician, the farmer, the merchant—each has his peculiar trials. If he amounts to anything among men he must do his work in spite of discouragements. The minister is no exception to the general rule.’’—LZiterary Digest. TOLSTOI AND THE PEASANT Not long ago a small party called on Tolstoi, of whom Ivanhoff was one. One of the visitors first conversed with the Count about political and social matters. Then Ivanhoff’s turn came. He was resolved to hear from Tolstoi’s own lips his religious position. The following conversation ensued. ‘‘Who are you?’’ asked Count Tolstoi. ‘‘I am only a peasant,’’ answered Ivanhoff. ‘‘What have you got to say to me?’’ was the next question. ‘‘I wish to know your opinion about Jesus Christ, and about the Holy Scriptures?’’ ‘‘With regard to Jesus Christ, there is nothing to be said,’’ answered the Count. ‘‘His Personality is not necessary to us, only his teaching.’’ (259-260) ‘“‘That is very strange,’’ said Ivanhoff; ‘‘if I found a letter in the street, the contents of which interested me, I would do all I could to find out who had written it. For me, at any rate, the writer is of more consequence than the letter. The writer can write one hundred other letters equally good, as this first letter. He himself, therefore, is of more interest to me than the letter. If I do not know him, I can only have this one letter; but if I am acquainted with him, I may be able to receive a hundred letters besides.’’ ‘CAs you really want to know what I think of Jesus, I will tell you,’’ said Tolstoi. ‘‘For me, Jesus Christ is a good man, a man such as all men ought to be. You and I ought to be just as he was. But to call him God, that is blasphemy. As regards the Holy Scriptures, take this Bible in your hand. The Old Testament, I don’t read it; rather tear it out and throw it away. The Old Testament only causes, as the Dukhabors rightly say, a great deal of work and only leads to trouble. Then there remains the New Testament. Take the book of Acts and the Epistles, and then take Revelation; tear them out and throw them away. You have then only the four Gospels left. Take these Gospels, read them through and think over them. There are words there that Jesus said, and the Apostles have written down; there are also words that the Apostles have written of themselves. All that the Apostles have written, tear out and throw away. Now you retain only the words that Jesus himself spoke. Of these, there are two classes. Some of the words are dim and mysterious, and hard to understand. Lay them aside. It is best for you not to read them. Then you have left only the clear words, especially the Sermon on the Mount. Read it, for it is the teaching of Jesus. In this way, you will become a Christian.’’ ‘‘Leo Nikolajewitsch,’’ answered Ivanhoff, ‘‘I have understood what you have said. But you have not given me any right to do that which you have said. In one of the books you left me to retain is a passage spoken by Jesus Christ, that says: ‘O fools, and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken.’ (Luke 24:25.) You said to me, that I should throw away the Old Testament; but Christ himself—whom you call a good man—has commanded me to believe it all, therefore also the prophets. I hold that I have no right to throw away any book; yea, even more, that I have no right to throw away any one word that he has commanded me to believe.’’ Tolstoi was evidently very uncomfortable. He took the Bible from Ivanhoff’s hand, threw it on the table, and began walking up and down the room in an annoyed mood. Suddenly he stopped in front of Ivanhoff, and looking him straight in the face said, ‘‘It would interest me to know what you think of me?’’ Ivanhoff’s friend wanted to come to his help, but he held him back saying: ‘‘If the Count had asked you, you could answer, but now he has asked me, and I want to an swer him myself.’’ He turned to Tolstoi saying: ‘‘I will tell you. In one of the books that you told me to take out and throw away, the Acts, is a story about a pious man, who gave many alms and always prayed to God. As you see, this man had the following virtues: He was Godfearing, merciful, did many good deeds, and he prayed— and yet, he was not a Christian. But an angel appeared to him and commanded that he should send to Joppa and call Simon Peter, who would tell him what to do to be saved. And when Cornelius had fetched Peter and heard his words he beeame a Christian. Cornelius had, as you see, the following exeellent qualities: He was pious, God-fearing, benevolent, and he prayed. In you, Leo Nikolajewitsch, there is not even all these, because you do not pray. And as you do not pray, I cannot call you a Christian.’’ Tolstoi again began to walk to and fro in the room. At last he said: ‘‘When a chicken has once come out of the shell, it cannot be put back.’’ With this Russian proverb, the conversation ended. ‘“‘T have since told this little incident to several of Tolstoi’s admirers,’’? adds Ivanhoff. ‘‘They could hardly believe that I had dared to speak out so freely, because Tolstoi is to many thousands of the younger Russians almost an idol. It is said,’’ remarked Ivanhoff at the close, ‘‘that Tolstoi has now begun to pray. If this man becomes a Christian, he would be Russia’s Luther.’’—Quarterly Review. MBS. EDDY’S ABSURD IDEAS OF THE BIBLE Mrs. Eddy’s exegetical theories are dealt with in the final article on the history of Christian Science in the June Af{cClure’s. The writer, Georgine Milmine, makes copious [4230]

This website uses cookies to improve the website and your experience. By continuing to browse this website, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. If you require further information or do not wish to accept cookies when using this website, please visit our Global Policy on Use of Cookies and Similar Technologies .